rosdistro: ROS Noetic November 2020 Regressions
There are a lot of regressions in Noetic, and it’s been a while since it had a sync. I think the following would get back to a sync’able state:
- Rollback moveit to
1.1.0-1because that doesn’t depend onros-noetic-fcl(Related to #26527, means reverting #26938 @tylerjw FYI)- rolled back in https://github.com/ros/rosdistro/pull/27402
- Upstream issue appears fixed by https://github.com/ros-controls/ros_controllers/pull/538
- Rollback ros_controllers to
0.17.0-1because that version built (means reverting #26904 @bmagyar FYI)- rolled back in https://github.com/ros/rosdistro/pull/27402
Ubuntu Focal amd64
Ubuntu Focal arm64
- chomp_motion_planner
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- jsk_pcl_ros_utils
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_perception
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_commander,moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros,moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_commander
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_core
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
fcl
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- moveit_fake_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_kinematics
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_planners_chomp,moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_chomp
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_plugins
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_fake_controller_manager,moveit_ros_control_interface,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_benchmarks,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_visualization,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_benchmarks
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_control_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_manipulation
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_move_group
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_kinematics,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_perception
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_robot_interaction
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_runtime
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_servo
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
Ubuntu Focal armhf
- chomp_motion_planner
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- jsk_pcl_ros_utils
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_perception
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_commander,moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros,moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_commander
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_core
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
fcl
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- moveit_fake_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_kinematics
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_planners_chomp,moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_chomp
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_plugins
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_fake_controller_manager,moveit_ros_control_interface,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_benchmarks,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_visualization,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_benchmarks
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_control_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_manipulation
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_move_group
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_kinematics,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_perception
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_robot_interaction
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_runtime
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_servo
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
Debian Buster amd64
- ackermann_steering_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- desktop_full
- Upstream packages blocking this:
urdf_sim_tutorial
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Failed to build ⚠️
- mir_description
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- mir_driver
- Upstream packages blocking this:
mir_description
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- mir_gazebo
- Upstream packages blocking this:
mir_description,mir_driver
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- mir_navigation
- Upstream packages blocking this:
mir_driver,mir_gazebo
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- mir_robot
- Upstream packages blocking this:
mir_description,mir_driver,mir_gazebo,mir_navigation
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- ros_controllers
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller - Upstream packages blocking this:
ackermann_steering_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- urdf_sim_tutorial
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
Debian Buster arm64
- ackermann_steering_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- chomp_motion_planner
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- diff_drive_controller
- ⚠️ Failed to build ⚠️
- moveit
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_commander,moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros,moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_commander
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_core
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
fcl
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
- moveit_fake_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_kinematics
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_planners_chomp,moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_chomp
- Upstream packages blocking this:
chomp_motion_planner,moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_planners_ompl
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_plugins
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_fake_controller_manager,moveit_ros_control_interface,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_benchmarks,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_visualization,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_benchmarks
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_control_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_manipulation
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_move_group
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_kinematics,moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_perception
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_robot_interaction
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_robot_interaction,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_runtime
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_planners,moveit_plugins,moveit_ros_manipulation,moveit_ros_move_group,moveit_ros_perception,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_planning_interface,moveit_ros_warehouse
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_servo
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_ros_planning_interface
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_setup_assistant
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core,moveit_ros_planning,moveit_ros_visualization
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- moveit_simple_controller_manager
- Upstream packages blocking this:
moveit_core
- Upstream packages blocking this:
- ros_controllers
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
diff_drive_controller - Upstream packages blocking this:
ackermann_steering_controller
- ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build:
About this issue
- Original URL
- State: closed
- Created 6 years ago
- Comments: 15 (13 by maintainers)
Oops, Debian Buster is only Recommend Support for ROS Noetic. I chose to revert
ros_controllersbecauseros-noetic-desktop-fulldepends on it, and it seems likely to be noticed since that’s the recommended metapackage to install.I’d recommend installing the
python3-ros-buildfarmpackage and running the Debian Buster dev job locally. Forros_controllersthe commands to do the Debian Buster amd64 dev job locally appear to beI pulled the debian source package and indeed it doesn’t comprise the latest release state. Looking into the debian source build job, I noticed that the correct source branch is checked out:
Invoking 'git clone --branch debian/ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1-2_focal --depth 1 --no-single-branch https://github.com/ros-gbp/fcl-release.git /tmp/sourcedeb/source'but subsequently, also an older tarball is downloaded:
Downloaded original tarball 'http://repositories.ros.org/ubuntu/building/pool/main/r/ros-noetic-fcl/ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1.orig.tar.gz' to '/tmp/sourcedeb/source/../ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1.orig.tar.gz'Shouldn’t the debian source package built from the branch? What’s the role of the tarball?Note, as the upstream package doesn’t yet have a new release tag, I created the new ROS release 0.6.1-2 from a git commit SHA.