rosdistro: ROS Noetic November 2020 Regressions

There are a lot of regressions in Noetic, and it’s been a while since it had a sync. I think the following would get back to a sync’able state:

Ubuntu Focal amd64

Ubuntu Focal arm64

  • chomp_motion_planner
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • jsk_pcl_ros_utils
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_perception
  • moveit
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_commander, moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros, moveit_setup_assistant
  • moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core
  • moveit_commander
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_core
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: fcl
  • moveit_fake_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_kinematics
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_planners
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_planners_chomp, moveit_planners_ompl
  • moveit_planners_chomp
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_planners_ompl
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_plugins
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_fake_controller_manager, moveit_ros_control_interface, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_benchmarks, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_visualization, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_benchmarks
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_control_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros_manipulation
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_move_group
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_kinematics, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • moveit_ros_perception
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_robot_interaction
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_visualization
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_warehouse
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_runtime
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_servo
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_setup_assistant
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_visualization
  • moveit_simple_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core

Ubuntu Focal armhf

  • chomp_motion_planner
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • jsk_pcl_ros_utils
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_perception
  • moveit
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_commander, moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros, moveit_setup_assistant
  • moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core
  • moveit_commander
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_core
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: fcl
  • moveit_fake_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_kinematics
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_planners
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_planners_chomp, moveit_planners_ompl
  • moveit_planners_chomp
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_planners_ompl
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_plugins
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_fake_controller_manager, moveit_ros_control_interface, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_benchmarks, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_visualization, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_benchmarks
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_control_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros_manipulation
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_move_group
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_kinematics, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • moveit_ros_perception
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_robot_interaction
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_visualization
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_warehouse
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_runtime
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_servo
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_setup_assistant
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_visualization
  • moveit_simple_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core

Debian Buster amd64

  • ackermann_steering_controller
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller
  • desktop_full
    • Upstream packages blocking this: urdf_sim_tutorial
  • diff_drive_controller
    • ⚠️ Failed to build ⚠️
  • mir_description
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller
  • mir_driver
    • Upstream packages blocking this: mir_description
  • mir_gazebo
    • Upstream packages blocking this: mir_description, mir_driver
  • mir_navigation
    • Upstream packages blocking this: mir_driver, mir_gazebo
  • mir_robot
    • Upstream packages blocking this: mir_description, mir_driver, mir_gazebo, mir_navigation
  • ros_controllers
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller
    • Upstream packages blocking this: ackermann_steering_controller
  • urdf_sim_tutorial
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller

Debian Buster arm64

  • ackermann_steering_controller
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller
  • chomp_motion_planner
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • diff_drive_controller
    • ⚠️ Failed to build ⚠️
  • moveit
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_commander, moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros, moveit_setup_assistant
  • moveit_chomp_optimizer_adapter
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core
  • moveit_commander
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_core
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: fcl
  • moveit_fake_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_kinematics
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_planners
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_planners_chomp, moveit_planners_ompl
  • moveit_planners_chomp
    • Upstream packages blocking this: chomp_motion_planner, moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_planners_ompl
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_plugins
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_fake_controller_manager, moveit_ros_control_interface, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_benchmarks, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_visualization, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_benchmarks
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_control_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_simple_controller_manager
  • moveit_ros_manipulation
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_move_group
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_kinematics, moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • moveit_ros_perception
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_occupancy_map_monitor
  • moveit_ros_planning_interface
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_robot_interaction
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_ros_visualization
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_robot_interaction, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_ros_warehouse
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning
  • moveit_runtime
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_planners, moveit_plugins, moveit_ros_manipulation, moveit_ros_move_group, moveit_ros_perception, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_planning_interface, moveit_ros_warehouse
  • moveit_servo
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_ros_planning_interface
  • moveit_setup_assistant
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core, moveit_ros_planning, moveit_ros_visualization
  • moveit_simple_controller_manager
    • Upstream packages blocking this: moveit_core
  • ros_controllers
    • ⚠️ Upstream packages that failed to build: diff_drive_controller
    • Upstream packages blocking this: ackermann_steering_controller

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: closed
  • Created 6 years ago
  • Comments: 15 (13 by maintainers)

Most upvoted comments

I probably missed the announcement that added Debian builds to the requirements for a distro release.

Oops, Debian Buster is only Recommend Support for ROS Noetic. I chose to revert ros_controllers because ros-noetic-desktop-full depends on it, and it seems likely to be noticed since that’s the recommended metapackage to install.

I’d be happy to run pre-release tests for debian too, could you please point me to a script generator for that?

I’d recommend installing the python3-ros-buildfarm package and running the Debian Buster dev job locally. For ros_controllers the commands to do the Debian Buster amd64 dev job locally appear to be

mkdir /tmp/devel_job
generate_devel_script.py https://raw.githubusercontent.com/ros-infrastructure/ros_buildfarm_config/production/index.yaml noetic db ros_controllers debian buster amd64 > /tmp/devel_job/devel_job_db_noetic_ros_controllers.sh
cd /tmp/devel_job
sh devel_job_db_noetic_ros_controllers.sh

I pulled the debian source package and indeed it doesn’t comprise the latest release state. Looking into the debian source build job, I noticed that the correct source branch is checked out: Invoking 'git clone --branch debian/ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1-2_focal --depth 1 --no-single-branch https://github.com/ros-gbp/fcl-release.git /tmp/sourcedeb/source'

but subsequently, also an older tarball is downloaded: Downloaded original tarball 'http://repositories.ros.org/ubuntu/building/pool/main/r/ros-noetic-fcl/ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1.orig.tar.gz' to '/tmp/sourcedeb/source/../ros-noetic-fcl_0.6.1.orig.tar.gz' Shouldn’t the debian source package built from the branch? What’s the role of the tarball?

Note, as the upstream package doesn’t yet have a new release tag, I created the new ROS release 0.6.1-2 from a git commit SHA.