desktop: [Windows] Portable version is not actually portable.

What happened?

Portable version downloaded from the website still stores profile data at \AppData\Local\zen, which makes it not portable at all.

Reproducible?

  • I have checked that this issue cannot be reproduced on Mozilla Firefox.

Version

129.0.2.3

Severity impact

Medium

What platform are you seeing the problem on?

Windows

Relevant log output

No response

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: closed
  • Created 2 years ago
  • Reactions: 2
  • Comments: 15 (4 by maintainers)

Most upvoted comments

@mauro-balades why is this issue closed? Don’t get me wrong, Zen is amazing, but the portable version on the website is clearly deceiving, I’ve never seen any other developer before using the word Portable to say “portable means the files can be moved” but when you move it, it can’t be used because your profile doesn’t move with it since it is not actually portable, so what’s the point here of this current “portable” version?! At least leave a message/warning on the website about this, because this is clearly not portable at current state.

I think this is inevitable because zen has originally played with the UI, such as vertical tabs.

Floorp Portable, Firefox Portable and Librewolf Portable are fully portable. Meaning, they save the profile in the same directory where the executable is. In all of the mentioned browsers, I could use/change the user.js and userchrome.css without problems. Floorp even has a built in menu for editing these files.

see here #804

Fair, but still doesn’t make any sense in having a “portable” version in your website, yet asking for a portable site to make a portable version of your project. Like I said, at least a warning to people would be nice, because at this moment is very deceiving, me and many others (from this issue alone) fell for that “fake” portable version.

No one said it was portable, it’s a generic version, built so that it supports older CPUs. Sorry

Zen is also a Firefox browser, so you can still use Firefox’s coding methods. However, you need to rename zen.exe to firefox.exe, then use the bat file provided in the link below and follow the instructions in the readme file. I have successfully made Zen portable, and all data is stored in the Profiles folder in the parent directory. Even if you move the directory, the data will not change, so you can safely copy it to a USB device.

Translated with [DeepL.com]

Your suggestion is to just create a profile in a different directory? That’s what you are doing

Rather, it is this way.

USER have multiple profiles up and running and in use at the same time,

https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/CommandLineOptions#User_profile

@echo off

SET BASE=%~dp0

SET MOZ_NO_REMOTE=true
start "ZenPortable" %BASE%\Zen.exe -no-remote -profile "zen_test" %1

I just tried the above command line, and it seems that a profile folder named zen_test is created in the same directory as zen.exe and uses that profile.

Please do not remove this from your code in the future. However, it seems that user.js, userchrome.css , userchrome.js , toolbar.uc.js that firefox user volunteers have prepared for customization cannot be used.

I think this is inevitable because zen has originally played with the UI, such as vertical tabs.

Oh right, the package is portable but not the browser