youtube-dl: Handle youtube CAPTCHAs (402 errors) gracefully
Upon encountering a 402 error, youtube-dl should:
- By default, throw out an error (“Due to high usage, youtube requires a CAPTCHA to be solved. Specify the
--captcha-solveror--captcha-interactiveoption to solve the CAPTCHA.”) - If the
--captcha-solverhas been specified, execute the specified program. Write the CAPTCHA image to its stdin and read its stdout. Enter the trimmed stdout as the CAPTCHA and continue downloading. - If the
--captcha-interactiveoption has be been specified, download the file to a temporary location and call['xdg-open', 'tmpfile']. If this fails, abort with an error message. Otherwise, callraw_input()and ask for a solution for the CAPTCHA.
Implementation notes:
- This is requires an option
captcha-solver. For the moment, I’m not sure whether it should be a Python callback(Fits better in a library) or a string(Allows serialization of options). - It will be hard to test. I can have a process downloading 24/7 from a high-bandwidth server until it encounters this problem, but there should be a nicer way to get youtube to present CAPTCHAs
- Afterwards, update the FAQ / documentation / README.md
About this issue
- Original URL
- State: open
- Created 15 years ago
- Reactions: 8
- Comments: 16 (2 by maintainers)
Links to this issue
- ytdl-org/youtube-dl: Command-line program to download videos from YouTube.com and other video sites - NotABug.org: Free code hosting
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- yt-dlp/README.md at 059cd768b97188fbbf3262696e6511f3aa1795e0 - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- yt-dlp/README.md at f412970164c349bea81bfd9d95e56fec7d16c8a1 - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- Ashish/yt-dlp - yt-dlp - SDF GIT Society
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 3bed621750b7fe25afc04a0131664bbbc610c563 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at b33a05d2213020fd4a74a1790db728a367f82517 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at cf80ff186eab6963fcfb108919a25b7ed28813d1 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 8d3a3a9901fa8ffdef84add5107f54d9d37050f2 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 3ae878605dd28461896e62f56e20bc50336c45bd - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at f8a12427a9ccdb8506be64c2b56eee7f8872ac3f - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 9d4424afaafe96161af59a8a59a0f922bd666fee - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 6797de75e059ec02ed91548ec8bfed8c89578344 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at cb7e053e0a6542b2db145c16291361e1f2d5ba2c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at d686cab084af88260bd28ad99673e27b36fcb4b2 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 8945b10f6e10337db0c9bf7a70758c8ecbb6c830 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 2e9ad59a4d6dfd82b34a965cfc5b8c5a647d1598 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at dbb18861148beed6630ebf895cd3f9e8165f75df - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 99534feaff3b437ddbf640cb2a69ae3900631a48 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at d332ec725db5b1102473a75b9fc3212913bda618 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 170f5b7c27f2e68b0a0a4e799647cbe780399fbf - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at a6e6673e825f6225c3a316b164ddca03fd20b5d2 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 2db9ac228d0f7ccc1d8078d5e29030665f0e3239 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 027ffdca0d3174963a4269ce8de8519cfed7a12c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at f8c7bed133fe729a9e26f23e5685559e3fa12eb1 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 86b7c00adca578b36138b165b0add5978972917e - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 831b732da1d0796a1927af8767d76af780cc90f0 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 45f4a433894556301204b704caca7d6a14286287 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 9d058b3206e431f19c955f9df3eaad34e7446f27 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 3f46a25a971b6c1e56747cc4813c1ccdfb18aaa2 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 974311b5aa1a53564a00915b9228af30e2a5b40d - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 80a51fc2ef3ebb7d3e3d5fd0b6e9942bb4be6f4d - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 90634acfcf9b106c9f5ac12bae5d92307cd577b0 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 10385322137eaf36b66b9e78931ea0a39e914c33 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at cff99c91d150df2a4e21962a3ca8d4ae94533b8c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 6cb30ea5eddb2db4a2536d1b851f4cc45f427d3c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at f5863a3ea08492bd9fc04c55e1e912d24e92d49b - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 82ef02e936a0e2ca698048c8cd79273a22e79867 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at b03eebdb6aab0f778293ed298543083b6ae76963 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at d65d89183f645a0e95910c3861491a75c26000eb - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at c56b2ac43ca27b32fb4f7b230d851a61b5fc7cbd - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at b1a92520a345178f82ff2ccd694700d4491c8b41 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at e35fc5ebc7eef38f8b354259849084f7a7b5ebb2 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 232331c0d2f446af760403ed5a0439cdc3deb112 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at eaba9dd6c2e2a06ceb0878c7f4dd06770b40cd0c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 9846935256a4e6398e6a16ec9ab18e45cba8f262 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 85b6335d55c7b0ed7f6815f7b8b9a365b0a28c37 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at dc27fd8bb8fc245155027d065861ef26d5137b7b - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 58ef5e788100dc338390e345a2744600e02e0f5c - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at fdc2183650a1aed22266bb59d83a1198525d4111 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 3fd86cfe13c2ca83c81cc43ed106152a07dcf012 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at ca7ebc4e5e03a79b90ffa509cd3ce6bbf65d43fa - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 841b683804c6f706554bf7607e52072575358445 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 42c971341b804b758d12b7a85547be05160f1b3d - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at afd4985f72a6641907aee1cd0b4b42da524b0ff4 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at ea07412ebf6fff7c17bcac9960cfe4e92ed62f12 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at f3914b06a0eb0f90b0a2326468e792f107968884 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 6104cc15915abfe113152d24b18c84178e027265 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- youtube-dl/README.md at 24510bdcfab3e450f9e1a1b82cf7fca4183c3333 - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
- protodrew/youtube-dl - youtube-dl - git.join-lemmy.org
Commits related to this issue
- Merge pull request #154 from rg3/master [pull] master from rg3:master — committed to joedborg/youtube-dl by pull[bot] 8 years ago
Hi phihag, here is the dump - http://www.grab.lv/_external/capture-libcapng
Steps made:
So basically you’d have to forcibly save cookie jar and save passed cookies (use_hitbox, goojf, I’m not sure about VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE) before and after authentication (only captcha filling should be done in a real browser), parse returned html page (goes via 302 redirect) and get iframe location. This URL should be passed to console, so user can click or copy-paste in browser. User fills the captcha in his browser, copies returned hash and pastes in youtube-dl. And again, same as step one - save cookies and afterwards - retry downloading.
Maybe you should take a look at Mechanize - http://wwwsearch.sourceforge.net/mechanize/ - unfortunately I’m not familiar with Python, but WWW::Mechanize works really well for Perl.
Just use this service https://anti-captcha.com/
Then let people submit their own login to it if they want to bypass captchas
I would suggest adding auto captcha solver from https://de-captcher.com/ or some other website because if you are using this to download vids for personal use than you won’t encounter captcha but if you are doing like making a website that downloads youtube vids, than you need a service. So a auto captcha solver service is best option.
In the docs there’s an option for that now:
–sleep-interval SECONDS
cheers everyone
What about adding OAuth 2 support so we can authorize our apps using this library against YouTube? This would solve the issue as far as I can tell.