WLED: SK6812 RGBW colors broken in 0.15.0 on ESP32, not ESP8266, works in 0.14.4

What happened?

I have two strips of SK6812s RGBWs, one lot attached to an ESP32 and one to an ESP8266

Updating to 0.15 from 0.14.4 breaks the ESP32 colors but not the ESP8266 colors

I’ve reverted to 0.14.4 so cant debug further at this moment but can do later

To Reproduce Bug

SK6812s RGBWs in GBR mode on an ESP32, the colors are the wrong. They are very dim, the hue isnt far off or might be right (havent fully debugged, had to quickly revert before the kids came home to see no xmas lights!)

Expected Behavior

Colors to be correct 😉

Install Method

Binary from WLED.me

What version of WLED?

0.15.0

Which microcontroller/board are you seeing the problem on?

ESP32

Relevant log/trace output

can provide later

Anything else?

Can debug further later, thought Id get this raised for everyones sake

Code of Conduct

  • I agree to follow this project’s Code of Conduct

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: closed
  • Created 2 years ago
  • Reactions: 3
  • Comments: 46 (1 by maintainers)

Commits related to this issue

Most upvoted comments

Anyone experiencig this issue (no white channel on SK6812 LEDs when using more than 5 outputs) please use the following workaround until this is fixed:

  1. Configure one of the outputs so that it has more than 300 LEDs (it can be unconnected one with no physical LEDs attaced and it can use any (unused) GPIO) or
  2. Reconfigure/rewire LEDs so that less than 6 outputs are used
  3. configure 8 dummy outputs followed by correct ones

Any extraneous LEDs can be hidden by adjusting segment size.

can confirm the behaviour is the same with NPB 2.8.3 @blazoncek I also tested your branch on S2, 5 outputs, SK6812 RGBW, same issue: white channel is zero edit: had settings wrong: it works on S2 both with NPB 2.8.0 and 2.8.3

@Deretour that’s what I figured. This is def a bug. I’m looking into it now too but not seeing anything glaringly obvious… I’m sure @Aircoookie will have this knocked out soon.

@Deretour try something. Delete a channel, any channel, so you have a max of 5 channels on your Octa. Do the other strips start behaving properly when there are only 5 channels?

OK, I couldn’t wait. 😃

Gave it a try and it’s exactly as expected: deleting one channel brings back blue for the remaining sk6812 channels. Unfortunately due to my wiring setup connecting two of the sk6812 strips to share one output/channel is not an option though. So I’m back on 0.14.4 for now.

I hope the test result helps narrow down the issue and it can be resolved in an upcoming release as there are definitely features in 0.15 that I’m looking forward to.

@Deretour try something. Delete a channel, any channel, so you have a max of 5 channels on your Octa. Do the other strips start behaving properly when there are only 5 channels?

It looks like the blue channel just doesn’t work for me with 15.0. I rolled back to 14.4 and it’s fine.

Same for me. For SK6812 strips I cannot get any blue to show up. Not even when intentionally switching color order. After reverting to 0.14.4 everything works fine again.

Affected binary: WLED_0.15.0_ESP32_Ethernet.bin Working binary: WLED_0.14.4_ESP32_Ethernet.bin

Upgrade performed via Home Assistant. Downgrade performed via WLED’s “Manual OTA Update”