ungoogled-chromium: Sites stopped working.
OS/Platform
Portable Linux
Installed
Other (please use ‘Additional context’ field below to mention how exactly)
Version
116.0.5845.96
Have you tested that this is not an upstream issue or an issue with your configuration?
- I have tried reproducing this issue in Chrome and it could not be reproduced there
- I have tried reproducing this issue in vanilla Chromium and it could not be reproduced there
- I have tried reproducing this issue in ungoogled-chromium with a new and empty profile using
--user-data-dircommand line argument and it could not be reproduced there
Description
Sites stopped working
How to Reproduce?
-
Go to https://aliexpress.ru Press Sign In button Enter email/password Slide the button to the right position
-
Go to https://lk.mts.ru
Actual behaviour
When I try to login https://aliexpress.ru a window pops up saying: “Sorry, we have detected unusual traffic from your network. Please slide to verify.” It doesn’t matter how many times you slide the button it reappears again and again.
When I try to login https://lk.mts.ru, site says: 403 Error Forbidden Access to login.mts.ru is forbidden. Try accessing the site login.mts.ru later or contact administration of the site.
Expected behaviour
-
Go to https://aliexpress.ru Press Sign In button Enter email/password Optionally: Slide the button to the right position You’re logged in
-
Go to https://lk.mts.ru A login window should appear
I have tested them with other browsers (thorium and firefox) and there they work as expected.
Relevant log output
No response
Additional context
About this issue
- Original URL
- State: closed
- Created 3 years ago
- Comments: 21 (6 by maintainers)
@h4ckee , you’re absolutely right, every site likely has its own unique “browser check-in” mechanisms, and trying to find specific workarounds for each could be a tedious and endless endeavor. I understand the appeal of using a separate, less privacy-focused browser for those specific cases.
However, juggling multiple browsers just for compatibility feels cumbersome. Ideally, a single browser could strike a balance between privacy and functionality.
I’ve reached out to the AliExpress development team, explaining the situation and hoping they might provide some insight into why Ungoogled Chromium triggers their security measures. Perhaps they can offer suggestions or adjustments that wouldn’t compromise user privacy. It’s a long shot, but worth a try.
IIRC there was a problem with the protection mechanism of the website itself, which would make it nearly impossible to even attempt to fix.
every site would be different in it’s “browser checkins”, so that can take a lot of time & effort to fix each and every misbehaving site with some kind of workaround, if possible. I’d use some additional “non-secure” browser for these cases.
It seems like you’re right, @h4ckee . It’s highly probable that these websites have implemented security measures that actively prevent logins or specific functionalities when they detect unusual behavior or are unable to track users effectively. This might involve blocking certain browser configurations, detecting the absence of specific JavaScript execution patterns, or other methods.
While it’s frustrating that we haven’t found a direct workaround within Ungoogled Chromium, perhaps we should focus on understanding these security mechanisms better. Investigating how these websites identify and block “unusual” activity might provide insights for potential solutions or workarounds.
Would you be open to exploring this further? We could start by analyzing network requests and responses during login attempts to identify any telltale signs or discrepancies.
I suppose that were sites’ settings which prevent from correct login etc. if they’re unable to track you or perform some other activity like javascript execution of specific code.
I already looked there but it’s not obvious where the problem is. Ok guys I don’t wanna bother you anymore, thank you for your time & patience.
Look in console of devtools. There might be some clues.
The question was about JIT.
Also please try reproducing your issue with an empty profile using --user-data-dir command line argument.
@h4ckee Do you have JIT enabled or disabled in website settings panel?
it works for me. Don’t think that the described behaviour is build-specific. h4ckee reported that this behaviour exists for some versions now… Maybe someone could verify that the same behaviour exits e.g. on windows?