tsduck: [Q] How to tune DVB-C/B aka J.83B 256-QAM transponder over terrestrial?
tsscan --nit-scan --delivery-system DVB-C/B -f 112750000 --debug -m 256-qam -s 5900000
doesn’t lock
dvbv5-zap -vvv -c channel.conf test
where channel.conf contains the following, works:
[test]
DELIVERY_SYSTEM = DVBC/ANNEX_B
FREQUENCY = 112750000
MODULATION = QAM/256
I see dvb-c/b has unsupported stuff in a bunch of places, what does that actually “mean”? Is there anything needed to support other than passing this tuning parameter to dvb-api?
About this issue
- Original URL
- State: closed
- Created 2 years ago
- Comments: 19 (9 by maintainers)
Commits related to this issue
- Fixed typo in delivery systems enum (issue #1518) — committed to tsduck/tsduck by lelegard 2 years ago
- Propagate subflavors of DVB-C in NIT scan (issue #1518) — committed to tsduck/tsduck by lelegard 2 years ago
Currently,
tsscanuses the NIT Actual only. The idea is to scan a network starting from a TS of that network. Therefore, on the initial TS, the target NIT is the actual one.AFAIK, the only ARIB specs containing signalisation are STD-B10 and STD-B21 (see bibliography) and they do not mention a cable descriptor.
The only spec I do not have access to is ARIB STD-B16 (ISDB Standard Digital Receiver for Satellite) which is not free and not available in English. Given the reference to satellite, I don’t think we could find anything about cable.
The only delivery system for which there is no signalisation is DVB-C (/A, /B, /C). So, the only case with a problem is a TS description containing a cable_delivery_system_descriptor. All the rest is addressed using other delivery descriptors.
We face only two cases:
Therefore, I will implement solution 1. We will see how it behaves. We count on you @trollcop to provide some feedback, when you are available, because you are probably the only TSDuck user who uses it on non-/A DVB-C networks.
Damn it! Thanks a lot for finding this. Another wonderful copy/paste story…
I will fix it right away. Because this enum/string table is used everywhere, including in the definition of option
--delivery-system, specifying--delivery-system DVB-C/Bactually resulted in using DVB-C/A.See the definition of option: https://github.com/tsduck/tsduck/blob/2ea222a3cb4ab6c7ce6f9fcd9a299b4f67618cee/src/libtsduck/dtv/broadcast/tsModulationArgs.cpp#L1443