armi: axialExpansionChanger and breakFuelComponentsIntoIndividuals() are not compatible
An internal plugin runs Block.breakFuelComponentsIntoIndividuals(), which tears apart the fuel inside of a block (with multiplicity > 1) into individual components and gives them multiplicity = 1. This appears to adversely impact downstream plugins as well as other parts of ARMI, which appear to not be prepared for this (i.e., multiplicity = 1).
An example of this breaking other code is in the axialExpansionChanger module. An internal plugin uses this module, and I observe a failure in AssemblyAxialLinkage._getLinkedComponents(). This failure occurs because _determineLinked() is returning multiple matches for a given pin by matching it with the many pins in the neighboring block(s).
About this issue
- Original URL
- State: closed
- Created 4 years ago
- Reactions: 1
- Comments: 16 (16 by maintainers)
Yes, it is definitely related. It’s the exact issue.
But the offending method of this issue is getting replaced and will be null in a few weeks. Once it gets removed, I was going to close this Issue (sorry, I could have communicated that).
@albeanth I would love to talk to you about the status of this issue. Since you are definitely the person who has the best eyes on it right now.
Ok, so #1376 will not resolve this issue. It will technically run through the linkage and give you something, but won’t be quite right I don’t think. It looks like it’d be moderate level of effort, but should be a PR separate from #1376. If we could leverage the grids in
breakFuelComponentsIntoIndividuals, that might help.The other (and arguably more complicated) issue we run into is determining the axial expansion target component on the fly. Up to this point, we’ve been able to get around this by manually setting it in the blueprints via
axial expansion target component. But that won’t work here. There may be other issues too, not sure yet.I would give a strong “yes”.
This is effectively the same as #769 , but this is a much more concrete, likely, and understandable instance of the underlying issue.