tailscale: Cannot establish direct connection / DERP servers slow

What is the issue?

Direct connection over cellular (mobile data) is not possible, falling back to relays 99.99% of the time. And then the DERPS are slow. I am in the UK, so nearest server geographically is London, yet Tailscale reports Madrid as the closest

Report:
        * UDP: true
        * IPv4: yes, xx.xx.xxx.x:57185
        * IPv6: no, but OS has support
        * MappingVariesByDestIP: false
        * HairPinning: false
        * PortMapping: UPnP
        * CaptivePortal: false
        * Nearest DERP: Madrid
        * DERP latency:
                - mad: 64.7ms  (Madrid)
                - waw: 66.1ms  (Warsaw)
                - lhr: 85.2ms  (London)
                - nyc: 92.5ms  (New York City)
                - mia: 116.1ms (Miami)
                - tor: 118.8ms (Toronto)
                - ord: 121.7ms (Chicago)
                - den: 127.5ms (Denver)
                - dfw: 130.4ms (Dallas)
                - dbi: 153.7ms (Dubai)
                - lax: 161.5ms (Los Angeles)
                - sea: 164.9ms (Seattle)
                - sfo: 168.4ms (San Francisco)
                - sin: 172.7ms (Singapore)
                - nai: 176.8ms (Nairobi)
                - hnl: 183.7ms (Honolulu)
                - jnb: 188.7ms (Johannesburg)
                - sao: 191.5ms (São Paulo)
                - hkg: 226.4ms (Hong Kong)
                - tok: 246.9ms (Tokyo)
                - blr: 277.3ms (Bangalore)
                - syd: 277.7ms (Sydney)

Tailscale ping shows I am indeed connect to London derp, but latency is high, with anywhere from 200ms, to as high as 900ms! Bug report from Linux machine: BUG-27ad229fc0e6ef459e126942d91cb8c118d16354e18b9329cc21862b505cfde2-20240212150557Z-aa6caf4a7dc97faa Bug report generated on Android device: BUG-59b18464c3a691025c7355c659faa95a77b7c96d699c139a481f55fdfeb7ca79-20240212150522Z-fe09d191bbf9997e Direct connections have been achieved, once or twice, but do not last long, falling back to relays

Steps to reproduce

Connect to tailscale via mobile data Tested across Android and iOS devices, across multiple mobile carriers (UK based, EE, O2 and Sky Mobile)

Are there any recent changes that introduced the issue?

OS

Linux

OS version

Raspbian 11 Bullseye

Tailscale version

1.58.2

Other software

Pihole with unbound as recursive DNS server

Bug report

BUG-27ad229fc0e6ef459e126942d91cb8c118d16354e18b9329cc21862b505cfde2-20240212150557Z-aa6caf4a7dc97faa

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: open
  • Created 3 years ago
  • Reactions: 1
  • Comments: 15 (1 by maintainers)

Most upvoted comments

I am experiencing a similar issue (no direct connection to my server over a mobile connection), but restarting Tailscale on the server makes it work for a while. Is it the same for others?

I also do have this issue, any news here?