symfony: New #[Route] attribute parameter `alias` does not work for localized routes

Symfony version(s) affected

7.3.0

Description

I’m trying to use the new alias introduced on the #[Route] attribute in 7.3, but getting unexpected results.

How to reproduce

with configuration

# config/routing.yaml
general:
  resource: '../src/Controller/'
  type: attribute
  prefix:
    nl_NL: /
    nl_BE: /
    fr_FR: /
    fr_BE: /fr
    en_US: /
  host:
    nl_NL: '%nl_host%'
    nl_BE: '%be_host%'
    fr_FR: '%fr_host%'
    fr_BE: '%be_host%'
    en_US: '%en_host%'

using

#[Route(path: [
    'nl_NL' => '/',
    'nl_BE' => '/',
    'fr_FR' => '/',
    'fr_BE' => '/',
    'en_US' => '/',
], name: 'default', methods: ['GET'], alias: ['my-alias'])]

yields Target route "default" for alias "my-alias" does not exist. from the template where i try to generate url(app.current_route)

but using

#[Route(path: '/', name: 'default', methods: ['GET'], alias: ['my-alias'])] 

yields Unable to generate a URL for the named route "my-alias" as such route does not exist. later on in the same template when trying to generate url('my-alias')

Possible Solution

No response

Additional Context

No response

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: open
  • Created a year ago
  • Comments: 15 (15 by maintainers)

Most upvoted comments

If aliases don’t work for other formats either, I suggest we document that limitation (and maybe add a better exception if possible) for 7.3, and that finding a way to support localized aliases gets handled as a new feature in a next minor version.

Ah rats, nevermind. Trying to write out a test scenario I actually discovered that this is probably not possible because the alias will only point to the last added locale of a route. There cannot be an alias for each localized entry because the alias entry is not localized and has to be unique.

Looks like the implementation of the alias property of the attribute has forgotten to consider the case of localized routes.