sats-connect: Failing to sign PSBT: Input script doesn't have pubKey:

I have created a funded P2WSH script, which is an HTLC. I now want to create a PSBT which will be signed by another wallet to withdraw the funds.

The problem is that the PSBT signing is throwing the following error: Input script doesn’t have pubKey. I am not sure why, or how to add this pubkey to the PSBT correctly.

The following is a details breakdown of the steps I am taking to create, fund and (failing to) redeem the HTLC.

Address from xverse (ordinals): tb1pnz86gezf5dzmja9q86z5agnmgjj29f00nxjj9jx0fsss6kkyh03sjkqhpd
Public Key: 59fff87c1bb3f75d34ea9d1588b72d0df43540695671c7a5ad3ec6a71d44bd79

Script to create the HTLC:

import bitcoin from 'bitcoinjs-lib';
import crypto from 'crypto';

function createHTLC(secret, lockduration, recipientPubKey, senderPubKey, networkType) {
    const network = networkType === 'testnet' ? bitcoin.networks.testnet : bitcoin.networks.bitcoin;
    const secretHash = crypto.createHash('sha256').update(Buffer.from(secret, 'utf-8')).digest();

const recipientHash = bitcoin.crypto.hash160(Buffer.from(recipientPubKey, 'hex'));
const senderHash = bitcoin.crypto.hash160(Buffer.from(senderPubKey, 'hex'));

const redeemScript = bitcoin.script.compile([
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_IF,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_SHA256,
    secretHash,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_EQUALVERIFY,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DUP,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_HASH160,
    recipientHash, // Hashed recipient public key
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_ELSE,
    bitcoin.script.number.encode(lockduration),
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DROP,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DUP,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_HASH160,
    senderHash, // Hashed sender public key
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_ENDIF,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_EQUALVERIFY,
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_CHECKSIG,
]);

// Calculate the P2WSH address and scriptPubKey
const redeemScriptHash = bitcoin.crypto.sha256(redeemScript);
const scriptPubKey = bitcoin.script.compile([
    bitcoin.opcodes.OP_0,  // Witness version 0
    redeemScriptHash
]);

const p2wshAddress = bitcoin.payments.p2wsh({
    redeem: { output: redeemScript, network },
    network
}).address;

console.log('\nCreated an HTLC Script!');
console.log('-------------------------------------------------');
console.log('P2WSH Bitcoin Deposit Address for HTLC:', p2wshAddress);
console.log('Witness Script Hex:', redeemScript.toString('hex'));
console.log('Redeem Block Number:', lockduration);
console.log('Secret (for spending):', secret);
console.log('SHA256(Secret) (for HTLC creation):', secretHash.toString('hex'));
console.log('ScriptPubKey Hex:', scriptPubKey.toString('hex'));
console.log('-------------------------------------------------');

// To fund the HTLC, send BTC to the p2wsh.address
// Redeeming the HTLC would involve creating a transaction that spends from this address
// using the provided witnessScript, which would be included in the transaction's witness field
}

// Example usage
createHTLC(
    'mysecret',
    1, // locktime in blocks
    "59fff87c1bb3f75d34ea9d1588b72d0df43540695671c7a5ad3ec6a71d44bd79",
    "59fff87c1bb3f75d34ea9d1588b72d0df43540695671c7a5ad3ec6a71d44bd79",
    'testnet'
);

This successfully creates the P2WSH transaction and gives the following output to the screen

Created an HTLC Script!
-------------------------------------------------
P2WSH Bitcoin Deposit Address for HTLC: tb1q5cyw034kcvsp6fsfx9skeq93vhvuqghmjc9y8xdhjll8m9thrn9q5mv0nr
Witness Script Hex: 63a820652c7dc687d98c9889304ed2e408c74b611e86a40caa51c4b43f1dd5913c5cd08876a914e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e06751b17576a914e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e06888ac
Redeem Block Number: 1
Secret (for spending): mysecret
SHA256(Secret) (for HTLC creation): 652c7dc687d98c9889304ed2e408c74b611e86a40caa51c4b43f1dd5913c5cd0
ScriptPubKey Hex: 0020a608e7c6b6c3201d260931616c80b165d9c022fb960a4399b797fe7d95771cca
-------------------------------------------------

Then I fund the script via xverse by sending bitcoin directly to

tb1q5cyw034kcvsp6fsfx9skeq93vhvuqghmjc9y8xdhjll8m9thrn9q5mv0nr
https://mempool.space/testnet/tx/be9cc0e300d1c01b7fdbeeff1c99acc0fb8a7d9e8d025547b7bfc9635dedcbb3

The ScriptPubKey on mempool.space seems to match mine

0020a608e7c6b6c3201d260931616c80b165d9c022fb960a4399b797fe7d95771cca Then it’s time to create the PSBT. I can’t immediately see any issues with how I am creating this PSBT. Do I need to add the public key somewhere?:

import * as bitcoin from 'bitcoinjs-lib';
import crypto from 'crypto';
import * as tinysecp256k1 from 'tiny-secp256k1';

// Initialize ECC library
import * as bitcoinjs from "bitcoinjs-lib";
import * as ecc from "tiny-secp256k1";

bitcoin.initEccLib(ecc);

function createSpendPSBT(secret, lockduration, scriptPubKeyHex, htlcTxId, htlcOutputIndex, refundAmount, recipientPubKey, senderPubKey, recipientAddress, networkType) {
    const network = networkType === 'testnet' ? bitcoin.networks.testnet : bitcoin.networks.bitcoin;

    const secretHash = crypto.createHash('sha256').update(Buffer.from(secret, 'utf-8')).digest();
    // Recreate the HTLC script using the provided secret
    const recipientHash = bitcoin.crypto.hash160(Buffer.from(recipientPubKey, 'hex'));
    const senderHash = bitcoin.crypto.hash160(Buffer.from(senderPubKey, 'hex'));

    const redeemScript = bitcoin.script.compile([
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_IF,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_SHA256,
        secretHash,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_EQUALVERIFY,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DUP,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_HASH160,
        recipientHash, // Hashed recipient public key
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_ELSE,
        bitcoin.script.number.encode(lockduration),
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DROP,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_DUP,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_HASH160,
        senderHash, // Hashed sender public key
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_ENDIF,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_EQUALVERIFY,
        bitcoin.opcodes.OP_CHECKSIG,
    ]);

    const scriptPubKey = Buffer.from(scriptPubKeyHex, 'hex');

    console.log("Creating PSBT");

    // Create a PSBT
    const psbt = new bitcoin.Psbt({ network: network })
        .addInput({
            hash: htlcTxId,
            index: htlcOutputIndex,
            sequence: 0xfffffffe, // Necessary for OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY
            witnessUtxo: {
                script: scriptPubKey,
                value: refundAmount,
            },
            witnessScript: redeemScript,
        })
        .addOutput({
            address: recipientAddress,
            value: refundAmount - 1000, // Subtract a nominal fee
        })
        .setVersion(2)
        .setLocktime(lockduration);

    console.log("PSBT to be signed:", psbt.toBase64());
}

// Example usage (Fill in the actual values)
createSpendPSBT(
    "mysecret", 
    0, 
    "0020a608e7c6b6c3201d260931616c80b165d9c022fb960a4399b797fe7d95771cca",
    "be9cc0e300d1c01b7fdbeeff1c99acc0fb8a7d9e8d025547b7bfc9635dedcbb3", 
    0, 
    1000, 
    "59fff87c1bb3f75d34ea9d1588b72d0df43540695671c7a5ad3ec6a71d44bd79", 
    "59fff87c1bb3f75d34ea9d1588b72d0df43540695671c7a5ad3ec6a71d44bd79", 
    "tb1pnz86gezf5dzmja9q86z5agnmgjj29f00nxjj9jx0fsss6kkyh03sjkqhpd",
    "testnet",
);
//createSpendPSBT(secret, lockduration, scriptPubKey, htlcTxId, htlcOutputIndex, refundAmount, recipientPubKey, senderPubKey, recipientAddress, networkType)

This gives me the following PSBT:

cHNidP8BAF4CAAAAAbPL7V1jyb+3R1UCjZ59ivvArJkc/+7bfxvA0QDjwJy+AAAAAAD+////AQAAAAAAAAAAIlEgmI+kZEmjRbl0oD6FTqJ7RKSipe+ZpSLIz0whDVrEu+MAAAAAAAEBK+gDAAAAAAAAIgAgpgjnxrbDIB0mCTFhbICxZdnAIvuWCkOZt5f+fZV3HMoBBVljqCBlLH3Gh9mMmIkwTtLkCMdLYR6GpAyqUcS0Px3VkTxc0Ih2qRTjmQVsTKY1caykT8LRGz/axpo34GcAsXV2qRTjmQVsTKY1caykT8LRGz/axpo34GiIrAAA

When I decode it, so I can inspect the contents, I get the following

{
  "tx": {
    "txid": "a1eaefe490f5d3be11fbd6a5afeffcff20a9e92cfde3363484168c9f5769c57a",
    "hash": "a1eaefe490f5d3be11fbd6a5afeffcff20a9e92cfde3363484168c9f5769c57a",
    "version": 2,
    "size": 94,
    "vsize": 94,
    "weight": 376,
    "locktime": 0,
    "vin": [
      {
        "txid": "be9cc0e300d1c01b7fdbeeff1c99acc0fb8a7d9e8d025547b7bfc9635dedcbb3",
        "vout": 0,
        "scriptSig": {
          "asm": "",
          "hex": ""
        },
        "sequence": 4294967294
      }
    ],
    "vout": [
      {
        "value": 0.00000000,
        "n": 0,
        "scriptPubKey": {
          "asm": "1 988fa46449a345b974a03e854ea27b44a4a2a5ef99a522c8cf4c210d5ac4bbe3",
          "desc": "rawtr(988fa46449a345b974a03e854ea27b44a4a2a5ef99a522c8cf4c210d5ac4bbe3)#4xpnet5r",
          "hex": "5120988fa46449a345b974a03e854ea27b44a4a2a5ef99a522c8cf4c210d5ac4bbe3",
          "address": "tb1pnz86gezf5dzmja9q86z5agnmgjj29f00nxjj9jx0fsss6kkyh03sjkqhpd",
          "type": "witness_v1_taproot"
        }
      }
    ]
  },
  "global_xpubs": [
  ],
  "psbt_version": 0,
  "proprietary": [
  ],
  "unknown": {
  },
  "inputs": [
    {
      "witness_utxo": {
        "amount": 0.00001000,
        "scriptPubKey": {
          "asm": "0 a608e7c6b6c3201d260931616c80b165d9c022fb960a4399b797fe7d95771cca",
          "desc": "addr(tb1q5cyw034kcvsp6fsfx9skeq93vhvuqghmjc9y8xdhjll8m9thrn9q5mv0nr)#wjcfmgw8",
          "hex": "0020a608e7c6b6c3201d260931616c80b165d9c022fb960a4399b797fe7d95771cca",
          "address": "tb1q5cyw034kcvsp6fsfx9skeq93vhvuqghmjc9y8xdhjll8m9thrn9q5mv0nr",
          "type": "witness_v0_scripthash"
        }
      },
      "witness_script": {
        "asm": "OP_IF OP_SHA256 652c7dc687d98c9889304ed2e408c74b611e86a40caa51c4b43f1dd5913c5cd0 OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_DUP OP_HASH160 e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e0 OP_ELSE 0 OP_CHECKLOCKTIMEVERIFY OP_DROP OP_DUP OP_HASH160 e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e0 OP_ENDIF OP_EQUALVERIFY OP_CHECKSIG",
        "hex": "63a820652c7dc687d98c9889304ed2e408c74b611e86a40caa51c4b43f1dd5913c5cd08876a914e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e06700b17576a914e399056c4ca63571aca44fc2d11b3fdac69a37e06888ac",
        "type": "nonstandard"
      }
    }
  ],
  "outputs": [
    {
    }
  ],
  "fee": 0.00001000
}

When I look at the inputs part of the PSBT, I can see that there is some input in there with my HTLC funds, and a scriptPubKey. Is this not the public key that the error is complaining doesn’t exist?

From there I tried to sign it anyway using sats-connect:

const signPsbtOptions = {
      payload: {
        network: {
          type: 'Testnet' // Change to 'Regtest' or 'Mainnet' as necessary
        },
        psbtBase64: `cHNidP8BAF4CAAAAAbPL7V1jyb+3R1UCjZ59ivvArJkc/+7bfxvA0QDjwJy+AAAAAAD+////AQAAAAAAAAAAIlEgmI+kZEmjRbl0oD6FTqJ7RKSipe+ZpSLIz0whDVrEu+MAAAAAAAEBK+gDAAAAAAAAIgAgpgjnxrbDIB0mCTFhbICxZdnAIvuWCkOZt5f+fZV3HMoBBVljqCBlLH3Gh9mMmIkwTtLkCMdLYR6GpAyqUcS0Px3VkTxc0Ih2qRTjmQVsTKY1caykT8LRGz/axpo34GcAsXV2qRTjmQVsTKY1caykT8LRGz/axpo34GiIrAAA`,
        broadcast: false, // Set to true if you want to broadcast after signing
        inputsToSign: [
            {
                address: "tb1pnz86gezf5dzmja9q86z5agnmgjj29f00nxjj9jx0fsss6kkyh03sjkqhpd", //should this be the address of signer or the address of the input?
                signingIndexes: [0] // Assuming you want to sign the first input
            }
        ],
      },
      onFinish: (response) => {
        console.log('Signed PSBT:', response.psbtBase64);
        // Here, you could add additional code to handle the signed PSBT
      },
      onCancel: () => alert('Signing canceled'),
    };
  
    try {
      await signTransaction(signPsbtOptions);
    } catch (error) {
      console.error('Error signing PSBT:', error);
      alert('Failed to sign PSBT.');
    }

and I was met with the following error

Input script doesn't have pubKey

My Question

Why doesn’t the input script have a public key, and isn’t this the purpose of scriptPubKey? How do I provide the public key correctly to sign this psbt?

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: closed
  • Created 3 years ago
  • Comments: 16 (8 by maintainers)

Most upvoted comments

Here is the React component I used to send it to the wallet:

import { useMemo } from 'react';
import { Address, BitcoinNetworkType, RpcErrorCode, request } from 'sats-connect';

type Props = {
  network: BitcoinNetworkType;
  addresses: Address[];
};

const Sign = ({ network, addresses }: Props) => {
  const psbt = 'cHNidP8BAFMAAAAAAbPL7V1jyb+3R1UCjZ59ivvArJkc/+7bfxvA0QDjwJy+AAAAAAD+////ASgjAAAAAAAAF6kU19NHmwjofrBjpTb5RqkbJBlj+GuHAQAAAAABASsQJwAAAAAAACIAIKYI58a2wyAdJgkxYWyAsWXZwCL7lgpDmbeX/n2VdxzKAQVZY6ggZSx9xofZjJiJME7S5AjHS2EehqQMqlHEtD8d1ZE8XNCIdqkU45kFbEymNXGspE/C0Rs/2saaN+BnUbF1dqkU45kFbEymNXGspE/C0Rs/2saaN+BoiKwAAA==';

  const paymentAddress = useMemo(() => {
    return addresses.find((address) => address.purpose === 'payment');
  }, [addresses]);

  const onSign = async () => {
    if (!paymentAddress || !psbt) {
      alert('Payment address or PSBT not found');
      return;
    }

    try {
      const response = await request('signPsbt', {
        psbt,
        signInputs: {
          [paymentAddress.address]: [0],
        },
      });

      if (response.status === 'success') {
        // handle success response
      } else {
        if (response.error.code === RpcErrorCode.USER_REJECTION) {
          // handle user request cancelation
        } else {
          // handle error
        }
      }
    } catch (err) {
      console.log(err);
    }
  };

  return (
    <div className="card">
      <div>
        <button onClick={onSign}>Sign</button>
      </div>
    </div>
  );
};

export default Sign;

You won’t be able to broadcast this transaction from the wallet as the wallet won’t be able to finalise it. You’ll have to use the signature sent back from the wallet in the PSBT to create the finalSig which will unlock your redeem script.