Roo-Code: Multiple bug and Horse Sighted

Which version of the app are you using?

latest

Which API Provider are you using?

OpenRouter

Which Model are you using?

claude sonnet 3.5

What happened?

i notice the Roo is very buggy but has potential and more skilled compare to cline in terms of coding and designing.

but after using it for 30 minutes i noticed a lot of bug.

1.Roo randomly removing const declaring ( js) or randomly removing import . ( when this happen i have to manually Reapply the removed before accepting the changes. ofcourse when i say Roo removed it, its actually causing error from client and roo not replaced it its just a mistake. 2. Roo does not know if i reject the modifcations, he assume that the code he is modifying is the one i rejected. 3. Hallucinated easily #related 2 and 1 4.Editing View tab. i cannot see when roo is modifying the code or not , it will only show whats modified when he is done to the coding task. 5. Horse Sighted. i dont know what to call this, but its like a horse with headgear, only see whats in front of him. explanation #5. example scenario. Roo add usestate ex. AllImages removes Image usestate as its a deprecated. (removed from declaration) but roo did not removed other Image reference. other scenario from my tests. i ask a issue about my scrapper: why my scrapper wont be able to suceed scraping movie data from tmdb? he modify my commented / disable code about movie and insisting that i need to remove comments to scrap movie. this code that i put commented is my deprecated function. new function handle two endpoints tv and movie. The issue he did not see that, and fail to analyze the code, when i say in my first prompt (analyze the file) and its core features. So thats why i called it Horse Sighted. Thsi is a very odd behavior that i did not experience on cline.

Steps to reproduce

1.nothing 2. 3.

Relevant API REQUEST output


Additional context

No response

About this issue

  • Original URL
  • State: closed
  • Created 2 years ago
  • Reactions: 1
  • Comments: 18

Most upvoted comments

apology for the buggy as fuck title, its not really what i really mean, im used for being a rude, im a keyboard warrior. but i dont really mean it.

but all those issues i mention is real experience with real use scenario or tasks.

its been a month since i open this issue, i learn a lot of cline/roo codebase. and i have use the extension for a month with a lot of experience in different scenarios. i already created 7 applications within the help of this extension.

i know now that most of my rant are common issues when dealing with LLM.

my issues in order:

  1. this is probably a context issue (LLM does not know the latest update file)
  2. this is gemini behavior that are not been solved until now ( model behavior ) probably prompt engineering will fix this
      1. issue
  3. this never happen again, its probably my vscode acting fuck at that time.
  4. 2 cases issue
    1. this is a Diff pattern behavior. model will create subtasks 1-2-3-4 for ex. and execute it one by one from single file ( this is a feature because its instructed, and with latest update now this kind of subtask can be executed only once. )
    1. this is probably a context issue again, and lacking of prompt clarification from me.

again i apologize for my shity behavior haha, i am idiot last month and i dont understand hows ROO/CLine and LLM works.

roo is doing a very good progress i am amaze, you will end up becoming a top one in openrouter very very soon.

For the horse-sighted part, we’re getting close on #1234. Thanks for the push!

this is insane

For the horse-sighted part, we’re getting close on https://github.com/RooVetGit/Roo-Code/pull/1234. Thanks for the push!