wishlist: Handshake failed error

When trying to connect to any server I’m receiving an error: something went wrong:failed to create session: connection failed: ssh: handshake failed: ssh: unable to authenticate, attempted methods [none publickey], no supported methods remain

I’m running wishlist in local tui mode, the config file is as follows (edited for privacy)

IdentityFile 	~/.ssh/id_rsa

Host		github.com
  AddKeysToAgent yes
  IdentityFile	~/.ssh/id_ed25519

Host 		*.mydomain.tld
  IdentityFile 	~/.ssh/id_rsa

Host 		foo
  HostName	x.x.x.x
  User		bar
  Port		222

Host 		baz
  HostName	y.y.y.y
  User		root
  Port		1774

Note: the public keys are confirmed to work normally, issues only arise when connecting through wishlist